Five Guys Milkshake Menu: Flavors, Prices, Calories
You’re here to find the Five Guys Milkshake Menu, with flavors, typical prices, and calorie expectations so you can order confidently.
At this chain the shake approach is simple and friendly: one classic vanilla base becomes many distinct tastes when you add free mix-ins like chocolate, peanut butter, or Oreo pieces.
Customization is the main draw. You pick a mix-in or two and the staff hand-spins it into a thick, creamy shake designed to pair with burgers and fries.
Prices and calories vary by location, portion size, and how many mix-ins you add. This guide highlights commonly seen flavors, typical price ranges, and what to watch for if you have allergies or dietary needs.
Expect a scannable roundup: flavor notes, best combos, pricing factors, and a quick dietary breakdown so you can decide fast and enjoy your order with confidence.
Five Guys Milkshake Menu Basics: What You’re Ordering in the United States
At the counter, your order always starts with a creamy vanilla base. Every shake is hand-spun: real vanilla ice cream blended with milk until thick, then finished to your taste.
How the hand-spun base works
Hand-spun means staff mix a vanilla ice cream base into a dense shake. They add your chosen mix-ins and blend them into one cup so flavors combine evenly.
Customization and availability
Customization is simple: you pick mix-ins and they blend them into one drink. Mix-ins are typically free, but exact choices vary by locations and by time.
- Dietary snapshot: dairy-forward base; nuts may be present; cookies add gluten; bacon is pork.
- Portion: most shops serve one full cup per shake — a dessert-sized treat.
- Order scripts to use: “Vanilla shake with peanut butter and Oreo pieces.”
| Item | Typical Cup | Dairy | Common Allergens |
|---|---|---|---|
| Hand-spun vanilla | One regular | Yes | Milk |
| Mix-ins (cookies, nuts) | Same cup | Depends | Gluten, Nuts |
| Seasonal items | One cup | Usually | Varies by item |
Next, the article breaks down common mix-ins and flavor notes so you can pick the best combo for your taste.
Milkshake Flavors and Mix-Ins You’ll Commonly See
Below is a quick guide to the most popular add-ins and how each one actually tastes.
Chocolate
Semi-sweet profile, thicker than syrup. Some locations call it “Fudge” or “Sauce.” Expect a dense chocolate note rather than a thin syrupy taste.
Peanut butter
Rich and candy-bar like. Think Reese’s-style flavor. Contains nuts—avoid if you have peanut allergies.
Salted caramel
Caramel builds after a few sips as it warms and blends. It starts subtle and grows sweeter and salty over time.
Coffee, Strawberry, Banana
Coffee is bold and slightly bitter—good for serious coffee fans.
Strawberry hits nostalgic strawberry-milk notes and pairs well with cookie pieces.
Banana reads sweet and old-school, like classic shake-shop fruit blends.
Cherry, Oreo, Malted milk, Bacon
Cherry is syrupy and polarizing. Oreo (Double Stuf) gives extra-cream and cookie-heavy texture.
Malted milk shines best paired with chocolate or vanilla. Real bacon bits add salty pops and texture—expect occasional bits through the straw.
| Item | Price (est.) | Calories (est.) | Allergens |
|---|---|---|---|
| Chocolate (Fudge/Sauce) | $4.00–$5.50 | 700–900 | Dairy |
| Peanut butter | $4.00–$5.50 | 800–1000 | Peanuts, Dairy |
| Salted caramel | $4.00–$5.50 | 750–950 | Dairy |
| Bacon | $4.50–$6.00 | 720–980 | Pork, Dairy |
Best Five Guys Milkshake Combinations to Try
Here are plug-and-play combos that make ordering fast and flavorful. Pick one hero flavor, add an accent, and finish with a texture for a balanced cup.
Sweet-and-salty
Bacon + salted caramel is an easy entry point. The bacon bits add a crunchy, savory pop. Caramel syrup warms the vanilla base and keeps the flavor focused.
Dessert-forward classic
Chocolate + peanut butter + banana reads like a candy sundae. It’s thick, rich, and ideal if you want a deep, dessert-style shake.
Fruity-and-creamy
Strawberry + Oreo pieces tastes like cookies-and-cream with a berry twist. The cookie bits give chew and contrast the bright fruit.
Balance and avoid a “muddy” cup
“Muddy” happens when too many bold mix-ins blend into a flat sweetness. Keep one hero flavor, one accent, and one texture.
- Hero: chocolate, coffee, strawberry, or vanilla.
- Accent: caramel, malted milk, or Oreo.
- Texture: cookie pieces or bacon bits.
| Combo | Why it works | Quick tip |
|---|---|---|
| Bacon + Caramel | Sweet meets salty; crunchy texture | Ask for extra bits for more crunch |
| Chocolate + Peanut Butter + Banana | Layers of candy and fruit richness | Great slow-sip dessert |
| Strawberry + Oreo | Fruit brightness with cookie chew | Perfect for sharing |
| Chocolate + Malted Milk | Old-school diner depth without extra sweet | Add a splash of syrup if needed |
Quick fixes: too sweet? Add coffee. Too bitter? Add caramel. Too plain? Drop in Oreo pieces for texture.
Five Guys Milkshake Prices and What Affects the Cost
Prices for a hand-spun milkshake often track the local market more than the flavor. In many U.S. areas a single shake lands around $6–$8, with tax nudging totals higher at checkout.
Why the price changes by location
Regional costs drive most differences. Higher rent and labor in urban centers usually raise the price. Franchise owners can set store-level pricing, so nearby shops may differ.
- Typical U.S. range: $6–$8 per cup before tax.
- Drivers: rent, wages, supply and local taxes.
- Value: mix-ins are usually free, so customers get a premium-tasting dessert in one cup.
| Item | Typical Price | Why it matters |
|---|---|---|
| Hand-spun shake | $6–$8 | One substantial drink that doubles as dessert |
| Extra mix-ins | Usually free | Boosts perceived value versus pay-per-add competitors |
| At-home option | Lower cost | A blender, ice cream, milk can replicate the experience |
Quick tip: if you must choose between fries and a shake, the shake often serves as a fuller dessert upgrade. Remember, dairy-forward and calorie-dense shakes are best as an occasional treat that fits your taste and diet.
Conclusion
Treat the shake like a short playlist: a steady vanilla base, a lead flavor, and a subtle backing note make a clean, satisfying cup.
Start with vanilla, pick one main flavor, then add one light mix-in so the cup won’t get muddy. Coffee is bold. Salted caramel builds as it warms. Chocolate stays semi-sweet. Bacon adds real salty bits.
Remember these drinks are dairy-based by default. Nut and cookie add-ins change allergen risks fast, so ask at the counter if you’re sensitive.
Use this guide to find a go-to combo you love, then rotate by season or spot. The best choice is the one that matches how you want your dessert to feel—classic, bold, fruity, or sweet-and-salty.
